Northumberland defeated Rapp County twice this season (home and away) and has a better overall win loss record than Rapp County. Yet, Rapp County is seeded higher and almost has as many points as 2nd seed Rappahannock Warsaw.
This type of situation has happened in many sports.
This system has way too many flaws. Head to head (if records are similar) should always come 1st, then maybe do points for tiebreakers. As I have argued before, this system does not work like it does for Football which has more advanced formula.
According to the system, ADs should just schedule mostly 4As and 5As, go like 2-14 and enter the tournament as a #1 or #2 seed. Or just schedule mostly 1A cupcakes and rack up the points that way. I wonder which one is better and would come out on top?