I don't think the Jefferson is a bad fit athletically for Louisa, aside from football, they are at best on par with the rest of the district. Louisa is a huge county centrally located between Charlottesville, Richmond and Fredericksburg. Spotsylvania High School (Battlefield, 21 mi) is the closest school to Louisa, Goochland (Jefferson 27 mi), Fluvanna (Jefferson 32 mi), Patrick Henry (Capital 31 mi), Glen Allen (Colonial 36 mi) & Deep Run (Colonial 36 mi) are all within 42 min of Mineral. Western Albemarle (52 mi) is the furthest JD team from Mineral, John Marshall (48 mi) & Varina (62 mi) are all around a 1 hr drive. The ENTIRE Colonial and Battlefield districts are closer than Albemarle and Western Albemarle to Louisa.
The powers that be at the Louisa School Board have an image of superiority to push, nothing more/nothing less. The athletics at Louisa (aside from football) can barely compete against schools 2/3 to 1/2 their size in the Jefferson. Prior to 2017, Louisa struggled to win the Jefferson in football, this recent run of talent/recruits is now gone, from a purely numbers and funding standpoint they should dominate the JD, only time will tell if they do.