We're talking DI here. Just look at the database. Most DIs are already in the double digits for commitments. Their limit is 25. Come back on Sept 1. The recruiting classes have already been rated and their commitments locked in. The competition for recruits is that fierce, the goal is to have everyone locked in by then.
Now, you're right about recruiting not being over. Plenty of DII and NAIA Colleges around that can offer schollies but if you notice, these don't appear in the Rivals database. Stories will appear on the board but it's really not considered recruiting. There's a major difference between DI and DII? Go to the games. See the facilities. Night and day. And this reminds me of something. The new JF weight room is better than any DII I've been to and I've been to a National Champion DII. Some good DIIIs out there but they don't offer schollies. Not allowed. Financial Aid....yes. And it always irks me when people post that player "A" has committed to DIII "B". An LOI is a commitment. To be more exact, it is a contract. DIII's cannot have LOI's, therefore there is no commitment. Anyone can play DIII. You just have to be a full time student.
Also, you don't "get found". Scouts are not randomly in the stands roaming around VA every week. This is a relationship business. It's a phone call to or from your HS Coach. That's where recruiting starts.
Absolutely nothing wrong with VMI. Fine school. Plenty of noteworthy alumni. But it takes a special person to go there and accept the Military structure. Just go to the database (again) and compare the # of commitments to a UVA or VT. Big difference even today. Come Sept 1, they'll still be sitting there at 3 or 4. UVA and VT will be at 25. No disrespect to anyone but these are the facts. Interprete them as you wish.
I can name a few DI players that received offers in their Senior year. It does happen. Can you name anyone with a Senior year schollie offer to a DI school?