I think someone on here seemed very rule savvy, so I have a question on leaping in HS. I have seen our players flagged for hurdling defenders and I have seen some hurdling on film not called (supposed to be 15 yd penalty). What is the rule? Is it a judgment call? I also wondered why the PH QB was not called for trying to leap over the pile at the goal line (twice). Even though he was unsuccessful, is that not the same idea? Someone had mentioned it in another thread, but man that was a heck of a goal line stand. A few penalties by both teams and it was like 9 plays long (included a few from the 5ish).
This, like most everything in football, is a judgment call. The only thing that is not a judgment call is the application of a rule or penalty enforcement. The governing rule on hurdling is in its very definition, NFHS 2-22. "Hurdling is an attempt by a player to jump (hurdle) with one or both feet or knees foremost over an opponent who is contacting the ground with no part of his body except one or both feet."
What does this mean in basic terms? If a player dives headfirst over an opponent (picture a player diving for the goal line with arms outstretched), that is legal. If ANY part of the opponent other than one or both feet is touching the ground, the "hurdle" is legal (picture a defender on his knee or flat on the ground, he can be hurdled). If the opponent has gone airborne (doesn't have a foot touching the ground), he can be hurdled legally. The only way this is a foul is if the opponent has only 1 or both feet touching the ground and the player "hurdles" the opponent, meaning he jumps over the opponent with one or both legs (foot/knee is specified in the rule) out in front of his own body. Picture how a track athlete jumps over hurdles with one leg outstretched, and replace the hurdle with another player. That's what they are getting at. Also remember, the runner can hurdle legally in NCAA. In high school (NFHS) NO ONE can hurdle! As you said, it is a 15 yard personal foul.
Also remember, hurdling can occur anytime anywhere, not just by the runner. A player hurdling the line (with their best Troy Polamalu impression) to block a kick can be, and usually is, hurdling. On this type of play, you have to see whether the lineman he hurdles has his hand off the ground yet. If the lineman's hand is on the ground, that's something other than one or both feet on the ground, so there's no hurdling foul.
Here are some examples:
This is a foul for hurdling in high school. Leg (knee/foot) is out in front of the body, and the opponent has a foot on the ground.
This is a foul for hurdling. Knee is out in front of the body.
Even though he failed and is embarrassed, this is still a foul for hurdling in high school. His knee was out in front of his body and over the opponent's head when he took off (this still image doesn't show that, but I saw the video clip)
This is the "jumping over the line" play I was referring to. In this scenario, the player is hurdling the snapper. If he jumps over the snapper, it's a safe bet the only thing touching the ground is the snapper's feet because his hands are off the ground releasing the ball. The hurdler's knee is out in front of his body, so this is a hurdling foul in high school. If he had jumped over the guard #63, there's at least a chance of his hurdle being legal because the guard's hand is on the ground in this picture. More than likely though, that guard will rise up quickly to block the hurdler, and we'll have a foul for hurdling. Honestly, the only way you will get away with jumping over the line legally is by diving headfirst like you're attempting to block the kick. On scrimmage kick plays (field goals, punts, etc), they also cannot contact the snapper as he is protected. Probably safer just not to hurdle the linemen than risk a 15 yard penalty and a probable 1st down for the offense.
This is
NOT a foul for hurdling because the opponent's knee is on the ground.
Last example. This is the traditional hurdle you see in high school football with the opponent ducking down to tackle the runner. This is a hurdling foul for the same reasons listed above.
Hope this was helpful!